Wednesday Special: $19.99 Cheese Pizza + One Topping • Tuesday: $1 Wings!


Family Owned and Operated For Over 20 Years!


Contact Muscarella's

  1. Home
  2. Contact

Call Your Nearest Muscarella's

Order by phone for pickup, or call with any questions. We have two locations to serve you.

Lancaster

470 Aurora St, Lancaster, NY 14086

Call (716) 683-1000

Lancaster hours, menu and online ordering

Williamsville

5526 Main St, Williamsville, NY 14221

Call (716) 204-9020

Williamsville hours, menu and online ordering

About Us:

Serving the suburbs of Buffalo, NY, Muscarella's Pizza offers a taste of local tradition with our acclaimed pizza and chicken wings. With convenient locations in Williamsville and Lancaster, we're a community favorite known for quality and convenience. Enjoy our signature dishes and easy dining experience, capturing the essence of Buffalo's vibrant culinary scene. Join us for a slice of local flavor!

Read More

Main Navigation:

Info & Employment:

Locations :

Lancaster:


Williamsville:



Copyright © 2026 Muscarella's Pizza. All Rights Reserved.